🔥 The DB Grill 🔥

Where database blog posts get flame-broiled to perfection

The only vendor standing: Elastic’s clean sweep in 2025 AV-Comparatives Tests
Originally from elastic.co/blog/feed
December 15, 2025 • Roasted by Dr. Cornelius "By The Book" Fitzgerald Read Original Article

Ah, yes. Another dispatch from the... industry. One must admire the sheer audacity, the raw, untamed confidence of it all. To claim "100% efficacy" is a bold stroke. A very bold stroke indeed. It speaks to a certain... freedom from the tedious constraints of reality that we in academia so often find ourselves shackled by.

It’s truly marvelous how they’ve managed to solve the fundamental challenges of distributed systems, apparently as a side project to their main security work. When they speak of preventing all compromises, I can only assume they have achieved perfect transactional integrity across their entire system-of-systems. The atomicity must be breathtaking. A security event is either fully committed and blocked, or it is not. There are no partial failures, no dirty reads of a potential threat. The consistency, isolation, and durability are, one must infer, absolute. They’ve achieved perfect ACID properties not in a sterile, single-node environment, but in the sprawling, chaotic mess of the open internet. Quite the footnote for a marketing pamphlet.

And the implications for the CAP theorem are simply staggering. Eric Brewer must be rewriting his notes. To provide a service that is always available and perfectly consistent in the face of network partitions... well, that’s not just an engineering feat, it’s a refutation of a foundational principle of computer science. I’ve been searching for the peer-reviewed paper on ArXiv, but it seems to be eluding me. Perhaps they announced it in a webinar.

One is forced to wonder about the underlying data model. To achieve this perfection, this "100% efficacy," they must have a schema of divine elegance. I presume it adheres to at least the first six of Codd's twelve rules for a truly relational database. Anything less would introduce anomalies, and "anomaly" seems rather incompatible with "perfect."

Elastic delivered 100% efficacy this year... the only vendor to achieve perfect scores throughout 2025.

And not only have they perfected the present, they’ve perfected the future as well! To have already achieved perfect scores for a year that has not yet occurred suggests a mastery over temporal data that makes Richard Snodgrass's work look like a child’s scribbles. They are not merely logging events; they are pre-ordaining them. Clearly they've never read Stonebraker's seminal work on the inherent trade-offs in system design, because they have simply decided that trade-offs no longer apply to them. It’s inspiring, in a way. The way a toddler’s belief that he can fly is inspiring, just before the tumble.

It's all so clear now. These "innovations" from the commercial sector aren't violations of first principles; they are transcendences. The rest of us are simply too buried in "proofs" and "logic" to see the truth that can only be revealed through a press release.

A fascinating piece of... creative writing. I shall make a note to never visit this... "blog"... again. The library is calling.